Menstruation is increasingly a non-event in films
Even in my high school, a former girls’ school where the vast majority of the students menstruated, theatrical disgusting was reacted when an unused tampon rolled out of someone’s bag. The popular culture at that time will have had something to do with that. It was around the period that Jonah Hill in teenage comedy Super bath (2007) starts to gag and gets in blind panic when he ends up with a beautiful woman at a student party after sanding with a blood stain on his pants.
The contrast with the omnipresent walking film The Good One – now in the cinema – can hardly be bigger. In the film, teen Sam Hiken goes with her divorced father and his also divorced friend. She has her period and director India Donaldson adds short moments in which the viewer sees Sam changing a tampon. First at home, while she chatting with her girlfriend, later squatting in the green, just outside the gaze of her hiking mates. Her period is a non-event in her life, as it is for most people.
In recent years, period is increasingly being discussed in films. And not especially to illustrate a female coming of age – as happened regularly in the past. Whether or not accompanied by shame, guilt and disgust – think of Carria (1976). Menstrual blood was sometimes ‘cute and playful’: in film hit The sausage person in the world (2021) Millennial Julie smears it on her cheeks during a paddot trip – even that cannot make her unattractive for her worshipers. It emphasized the ‘animal’ sides of characters, as in horror comedy Nightbitch (2024) in which a frustrated home worker turns into a dog. While her partner nags about the milk she has forgotten to buy, she takes her first shower tired in days and the water turns towards the well red. And it didn’t have to stand in the way of eroticism, as in Saltburn (2023) or thriller Fair Play (2023).
In itself it is positive that nowadays such a diversity of menstrual images can be found in films, both in the work of male and female makers. The change probably has to do with the increased attention for the representation of women and the current spirit of the times. Even Chatgtp mainly advises me to « stay respectful on sensitive topics » when I ask if he still knows a nice menstrual steak.
Yet I sometimes look at these scenes with discomfort; Occasionally they feel something dragged with the hair. Is in the historic drama Mary Queen of Scots, About the bond between Mary Stuart and Elizabeth I, is it really added value to see court ladies with Mary’s menstrual blood? It has little plot value and seems to be added to make a statement.
Bee The Good One I never thought so; Not only because it is portrayed so everyday. Also because Sams tampon changes are really part of the story; It makes it visually clear that as the trip progresses, it becomes more difficult for Sam to find a place where she feels safe. Although I also thought after the fourth change: now I am noticing.
One of the smartest menstrual scenes is at the start of the further sinister film September Says (2024). Teen September is with her mother in underwear in the bathroom. Mother’s sanitary napkin is visible while they cleaning dancing. Menstrualization is not disguised as disgusting, but is something completely everyday that yields a visually witty moment.